You Scream, I Scream…We all Scream for Ice Cream
A Trip to Salem Without Ice Cream? Now That’s a Frightening Thought!
Anyone who knows me, knows that I am an Ice Cream enthusiast. I once had several pints shipped up to the Witch House from Leopold’s in Savannah for a 50th birthday party. (Sidebar, if you’re ever in Savannah, you have to try Leopold’s Ice Cream….or don’t because it might ruin every other ice cream that you’ll ever have - it’s THAT good!)
So now that you know my standards of Ice Cream are insanely high, I’ll throw out a few local recommendations that won’t have you 2-day shipping your favorite flavors in a Styrofoam cooler with blocks of dry ice like a lunatic.
Richardsons Farm - Middleton, MA
I’ll start with the Gold Standard. Richardson’s Ice Cream. No list of North Shore ice cream is complete without Richardson’s. Open since 1695 (yes, you read that right) Only three years after the infamous Witch Trials, David Richardson moved from Woburn to Salem Village, which is now part of Middleton, Massachusetts to start Richardson's Farm. Richardson’s is a working dairy farm where the cows are still on-site. With dozens of flavors—from classics like butter pecan to specialties like grapenut—it’s worth the drive out to Middleton. Pro tip: after your cone, you can visit the driving range or mini golf right next door. This is a 20 minute drive from the house, and on summer nights (especially weekends) expect the lines to get pretty long.
Dairy Maid - Everett, MA
My personal favorite. This is about a 20 minute drive from the Witch House, but there is something magical about this place. Dairy Maid has that old-school ice cream stand charm that just feels like summer. It’s simple, nostalgic, and has been around for decades. Their sundaes and frappes are huge hits. They also give out free pup cups for your four-legged companions. This is a small Ice Cream stand, but there is something nostalgic about popping the trunk and sitting on the hitch eating your ice cream in the parking lot. My personal favorite is the Reese’s Pieces Hot Fudge Sundae.
E.W. Hobbs & Holy Cow - Salem, MA
Salem Willows isn’t just about arcades and fried clams—it’s also home to some of the area’s best ice cream. E.W. Hobbs is famous for its popcorn and ice cream, serving up big scoops with that old-fashioned boardwalk feel. If you’re looking for something a little more gourmet, Holy Cow has become a fan favorite, with creative, small-batch flavors like “Banana’s Foster” or “Salty Caramel Truffle.” Perfect for enjoying as you wander the Willows or stroll down the new pier.
Treadwell’s Ice Cream - Peabody, MA
Another North Shore institution, Treadwell’s has been serving since 1946. Known for its generous portions and rich, creamy texture, this place has lines out the door on hot summer nights. From frappes to sundaes, it’s the kind of place where “just one scoop” always turns into two.
Cookie Monstah - Multiple locations (Danvers, Swampscott, Beverly and their Food Truck in Boston)
Sometimes, a scoop just isn’t enough—you need it sandwiched between two cookies. That’s where Cookie Monstah comes in. With trucks and shops around the North Shore, including Salem, they’ve perfected the art of the ice cream sandwich. Mix and match cookies and flavors (chocolate chip + mint chip is a classic combo) for a treat that’s as Instagram-worthy as it is delicious. The closest location to the house is in Swampscott. Just a mere 10 minutes from the Witch House.
Putnam Pantry - Danvers, MA
Three words: ICE.CREAM.SMORGASBORD! Since 1951, Putnam Pantry has been delighting North Shore locals and visitors alike with handmade chocolates, candies, and a cozy café set inside a converted shoe factory. It’s a family-run spot filled with nostalgia, charm, and plenty of sweetness - the pièce de résistance is without question their legendary Ice Cream Smorgasbord. Here, you start with scoops of ice cream and then help yourself to an overflowing buffet of toppings — from candies and sauces to fruits, nuts, and whipped cream — creating a sundae masterpiece as unique as you are. With so many topping and flavors to choose from, you’ll just have to keep coming back for more!
